Permlink | Comments
By: Anton McClure;
Last Updated:
Tags: Opinion; Technology; Tildeverse;

My thoughts on comments and other public feedback systems.

Icon by OpenClipart-Vectors. Image licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.
Icon by OpenClipart-Vectors. Image licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

After reading James Tomasino's article "Comments" and having some discussions on the issue via IRC, I began questioning whether or not comment systems such as Disqus and public feedback systems, in general, were beneficial.

When you read something and want to interact with it, what drives you to do so? Do you want to show appreciation, agreement, disagreement, suggest corrections, or carry on a conversation? While comment threads, like any conversation, can get hijacked away from the intended discussion, it doesn't necessarily mean that having a public feedback option is not helpful for social systems, unless the feedback option's purpose is for harm instead of benefit.

Conversation hijacking will always be an issue, regardless of the platform. For example, I could have gone off-topic with how's formerly used Disqus, but doing so isn't worth the time and effort of a blog post.

At the end of the day, if someone wants to contact the author for anything, I feel they should be able to use whatever suits them best. With multiple options existing, site admins have the choice to pick the methods they prefer most and let users decide which of the options they prefer as well.

My rambling aside: I think that Tomasinos right. If you want to comment on a post, feel free to see my contact page.

Also on:

About the Author

Recent Posts

Image from piqsels. Licensed under public domain.
How Software as a Service (SaaS) Can Improve Your Business

By: Anton McClure;
Published: July 1, 2020
Tags: Technology; SaaS; Business;
You want your business to be successful, and modern cloud technologies such as SaaS can help make that success happen.

Title card - Image features an SSH connection Lily Winter's
How to Get Started with Tildes

By: Anton McClure;
Published: June 30, 2020
Tags: Technologies; Tildes; Open Computing;
Many public-access servers called "tildes", many of which are actively accepting new users. Here's how you can join and start making the most of your new tilde account.

Image by Pete Linforth (TheDigitalArtist). Image licensed under the Pixabay License.
Microsoft Gives Linux and Android a Significant Security Upgrade

By: Anton McClure;
Published: June 24, 2020
Tags: Android; Linux; Microsoft; Security;
Microsoft has released their Defender ATP platform for Linux and Android devices. Here are some of the benefits it brings, and how you can deploy it.

Image from pxfuel. Free for commercial use.
Making the Internet and its Content Accessible for More People

By: Anton McClure;
Published: June 14, 2020
Tags: General; Internet;
Mobile devices are bringing the Internet to more people than ever before. Here's ways we can improve their online experience.

Screenshot from me deleting a WordPress site from my VPS.
(Why) I Won't Use WordPress, and Why You Shouldn't Either

By: Anton McClure;
Published: June 5, 2020
Tags: Technology; Alternatives; Security; Internet;
WordPress is popular, but there are better programs out there.

Image by OpenClipart-Vectors. Image licensed under the Creative Commons Zero (CC0) license.
Zoom Free Users Will Not Have End-to-End Encryption

By: Anton McClure;
Published: June 4, 2020
Tags: Technology; Encryption; Alternatives;
Zoom CEO has stated free users will not get end-to-end encryption. Here are some good alternatives to Zoom you could use instead.